Students march, hold vigil after Gaza aid attack

Stanford students and community members held a candlelight vigil on Tuesday night and a protest on Wednesday afternoon in response to the Israeli attack on a flotilla of activists carrying aid to Gaza on Monday.

The vigil, which took place between Meyer and Green libraries at 9 p.m. on Tuesday, mourned the nine deaths that resulted from Monday’s attack.

People gathered on Tuesday between Meyer and Green libraries at Stanford to hold a vigil in response to the Israeli attack on a flotilla of activtists carrying aid to Gaza. (JONATHAN POTO/The Stanford Daily)

Geoff Browning, a minister for United Campus Christian Ministry and a staff member in the Office of Religious Life, led a prayer before Jenna Queenan ’11, the incoming president of Students Confronting Apartheid by Israel, asked for a few minutes of silence while the crowd lit candles.

Queenan emphasized the importance of putting the attack in context, but “not necessarily a political context.”

Adam Hudson ‘10 encouraged those present to pressure the American government to change its policy toward Israel.

“The very government that runs our country is the biggest sponsor of Israeli military aggression,” Hudson said. “We can choose to be apathetic, or we can take a good look at what our government does.”

Hudson also said the conflict was about more than religion.

“This is a conflict about humanity,” he said.

Joe Gettinger ‘11, former president of the Jewish Student Association, knew many people present at the vigil and noted the diversity of the group.

“The range of people is quite impressive,” he said. “We all agree that the loss of life is condemnable.”

Former ASSU Senator Mohammad Ali ‘10, one of the vigil organizers, said the purpose of the event was to “commemorate those who gave their lives while delivering humanitarian aid.”

“This is an issue that really matters to a lot of people, regardless of your political beliefs,” Ali said.

“It’s a kind of a shame for humanity, trying to defend what happened over there,” added Zahit Guner of Turkey.

Students acknowledged and appreciated the increase in awareness.

“This needs to bring light to the fact that there is a humanitarian crisis in Gaza,” said Salahodeen Abdul-Kafi ’12. “I’m glad that people are finally starting to talk about the blockade.”

Chloe English ‘13, who is involved with Invest for Peace, an initiative associated with Stanford Israel Alliance, said the responsibility of Stanford students is to “scrutinize and question” events such as the Gaza flotilla attack.

“This was an example of an appropriate response,” English said of the vigil.  “Ultimately, what most Jews want — in Israel and around the world — is peace.”

The somber tone of Tuesday night’s vigil contrasted sharply with the character of Wednesday afternoon’s protest.

Zaid Adhami '10, right, Jenna Queenan '11, second from right, and other students marched in White Plaza on Wednesday in response to Monday's international incident. (MASARU OKA/Staff Photographer)

“Freedom is never voluntarily given by the oppressor,” declared Fadi Quran ’10, an organizer of recent divestment movement Campaign Restore Hope, over a megaphone in White Plaza. “It must be demanded by the oppressed.”

After gathering in White Plaza, protesters marched by Tresidder Union, Meyer Library and Coupa Café. Those involved sang “We Shall Overcome” and chanted, “End the occupation.”

Several students associated with the Stanford Israel Alliance were also in White Plaza handing out fliers.

“The aim of the Gaza flotilla was not simply to provide humanitarian relief, it was also to provoke reaction from Israel,” read the fliers.

Jaclyn Tandler ‘11, president of the Stanford Israel Alliance, defended the Israeli blockade of Gaza.

“We believe that it is a just means to protect Israeli citizens in southern cities,” she said.

Tandler said she hoped that Monday’s events wouldn’t impede future peace efforts in the Middle East.

After Wednesday’s march, Quran said the purpose of the rally was to “spread awareness about the issue” and to “remind people that there is a blockade going on.”

“I think Stanford students really get stuck in the Stanford bubble,” said Mai El-Sadany ‘11. “It’s our role as Stanford students to get involved with what’s happening around the world.”

  • amgillespie

    It is worth noting that Egypt has also had a blockade of Gaza since 2007. I wonder if this concerns Ms. Queenan or Mr. Hudson, even though it has been done to Gaza by an Arab nation.

  • Hudson

    You’re right. Egypt has blockaded Gaza. Although Israel controls most of Gaza’s borders (around 2/3 while Egypt controls the Rafah border) and Egypt wasn’t the country that raided the flotilla. Next to Israel, Egypt is the number-2 recipient of U.S. foreign aid. Even more reason to question and hold the United States government accountable for its policies in the region.

  • Israeli Prime Minister said

    “My opinion of Christian Zionists? They’re scum. But don’t tell them that. We need all the useful idiots we can get right now,”
    — Benjamin “Bibi” Netanyahu

  • Johnny

    What a fantastically biased article! Bravo, Daily, on giving a microphone to people who are lying straight through their teeth. There are videos of Israeli commandos being attacked as soon as they landed on the ships. But sure, it was peaceful.

  • Israeli Prime Minister said

    it disgusts me to see how brainwashed, or stupid, some people at Stanford are.

  • Ed Hua

    Anyone who believes that the people on the ship had peaceful motives are either ignorant or knows the truth but doesn’t care because of their knee jerk hate against Israel. Go look at the videos of the incident instead of thinking like a sheep.

  • Danny Colligan

    It’s incredible that some continue to defend Israel’s barbaric act of murder and piracy in international waters. The “discussion” we are having on the Daily comment threads is light years away from the civilized discussion last night by Profs. Benin and Zipperstein, both of whom strongly condemned the attack. Why can’t more American Jews look to the best of the Jewish community for guidance and leadership instead of the worst (Netanyahu, Lieberman, etc.)?

  • Supra

    So the “best” of the Jewish community are those that agree with you and the “worst” are those that disagree? What an enlightened view.

  • Mary

    Is anyone stupid enough to believe these were innocent aid workers? They were trying to lynch the soldiers and were armed and ready. From the begging the flotilla had nothing to do with aid but with garnering publicity. That is why they refused the Israelis offer to deliver the aid after an inspection for weapons or bomb material.
    I guess some people in the Stanford community are too easily swayed by people who deceptively use the title of “aid worker”.

  • M. Banerji

    What do these armed and violent activists expect when against warnings enter the territory of another country and attempt to kill the country’s soldiers who try to stop them.
    Let’s see them bring an aid flotilla to North Korea, where people are really starving. I doubt the North Koreans would use paintball guns to stop the ship, they’d probably blow the whole thing up. Ironically, you wouldn’t see any outcry from people like these protesters (have we seen any outcry of the sinking of the South Korean Ship?). They don’t care about human rights or justice, they care about demonizing Israel in any form possible.

  • Sharia

    You can say all that you want, but in the end, the Israeli military killed nearly a dozen people (wounding 60) while the Flotilla activists killed no one. Saying they instigated their own death is irreverent to those that died for a cause they believed in and still does not warrant the excessive use of force. Whether you love Israel or not does not matter; love means that you criticize unreasonable actions and encourage accountability.

    Moreover, the Gaza blockade is barbaric and contrary to any ideals of human rights. To say that subjugating 1.5 million people is a way to “protect” oneself denotes Israel’s dehumanization and distrust of an entire people (who mind you, do not get the $3 billion of, mostly military, aid from the USA). This is the same flawed rhetoric which fueled racist Jim Crowe laws and the eugenic “science” which led to Nazism. And remember, Israel is only second to the USA in having the most nuclear warheads and missiles. There is NEVER a justification for systematic oppression of a people.

  • USA Today letter

    Letter in USA Today says it well:

    “If a group of supporters of terrorism in America announced they were going to sail ships full of supplies to our shores without going through customs, the U.S. Coast Guard would be expected to intervene. If the terror supporters on those boats then attacked the Coast Guard with knives, metal bars and guns, most likely they would be shot and their ships sunk.
    When Israel tries to prevent supplies from going to terrorists firing missiles at towns and villages, many nations rush to condemn it.
    Preventing Israel from guaranteeing its own security will never promote peace in the region.”

  • amgillespie

    @Hudson: So where is the march, the vigil, the rush to judgment, the outrage on campus when Egypt attacks an aid convoy heading to Gaza (http://www.tehrantimes.com/index_View.asp?code=211588)? Where is the “Students Confronting Apartheid in Egypt” group condemning the treatment of Coptic Christians and other minorities in Egypt? This false outrage against Israel is completely disingenuous. It is not about “humanity”. Don’t kid yourself. It’s just politics.

  • Turkish terror ties

    The so-called “humanitarian” group has terror ties.

    http://news.yahoo.com/s/ap/20100602/ap_on_re_eu/eu_gaza_ships_terror_ties

    Those of you who are so concerned about human rights, start demonstrating and protesting suicide bombings and hostage taking (since that REALLY violates human rights). When Hamas returns the young hostage Gilad Schalit, we will have more to discuss.

  • Ben

    Let them sail. Natural selection at work.

  • dear mr banerji

    you said “What do these armed and violent activists expect when against warnings enter the territory of another country and attempt to kill the country’s soldiers who try to stop them.”
    I guess you havent been following this closely enough (or at all for that matter) BECAUSE THE SHIP WAS IN INTERNATIONAL WATERS!!!! THEY DID NOT ENTER iSRAEL’S TERRITORY. THEY ATTACKED PIRATES WHO ILLEGALLY BOARDED THE SHIP AND ATTEMPTED TO HIJACK IT. those who died on the ship were heroes, the israeli soldiers who were attacked were stupid pirates.

  • Mr. Banerji

    If you knew anything about law, a country has full rights to stop a vessel in international waters if the vessel’s crew has made it clear it intends to breach that country’s sovereign territory. Furthermore, Israel did not “attack” the flotilla, but was engaged by violent activists who tried to lynch them.

  • Stanford alumna

    The Turkish group had terrorism ties.

    See the link below:
    http://news.yahoo.com/s/ap/20100602/ap_on_re_eu/eu_gaza_ships_terror_ties

    “The Turkish Islamic charity behind a flotilla of aid ships that was raided by Israeli forces on its way to Gaza had ties to terrorism networks, including a 1999 al-Qaida plot to bomb Los Angeles International Airport…”

    Gaza blockade is far from barbaric, but is a very restrained response to rockets and bombs targeting Israeli civilians. In addition, Gilad Shalit still has not been released, and the Red Cross has no access to him. Sounds like a violation of human rights to me.

  • Anonymous
  • john

    Why are there no demonstrations against the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan? Far more than 11 people killed there. Innocent civilians killed nearly weekly yet no one on campus is motivated to protest. Why is that?

  • Cory

    Because the protester’s aren’t concerned with human rights, but rather a religious and political hate against Israel. You won’t see them protest over deaths in Afghanistan, Darfur, Iran, North Korea, Congo, Burma, ect. They’d rather protest against Israel for trying to stop armed activists after offering to deliver the “aid” after it was checked for weapon and bomb materials.

    It is obvious to anyone with half a brain and some knowledge of the situation that the protests would not be taking place if Israel were a Muslim country rather than a Jewish one.

  • Stanford alumna

    Hey, now this is closer to the truth – 7 facts you need to know to understand the situation.
    http://news.yahoo.com/s/csm/20100603/cm_csm/305744

  • Xinwai Ho

    I love Israel.

  • @USA Today Letter

    Your analogy is flawed. Israel’s actions are more like, let’s say if the United States placed a navy blockade on Cuba and then machine gun’d anyone who attempted to bring aid to the Cuban people. Stop using terrorism fear tactics. It’s not 2003 anymore.

  • Harry

    The difference between Cuba today and Hamas today is that Cuba hasn’t lobbed rockets onto Florida or other states in the Gulf. That’s why there is only a trade embargo on Cuba. Both Cuba and Hamas are being pressured to change, while Hamas’ situation creates the need for something extra. Hamas isn’t a toy you’d give your baby to play with, let’s get real.

  • Martin

    Beinin is considered a reputable source for condemning Israel? His class is one big joke. He obfuscates and lies through his teeth. May as well interview Sa’eb Erakat

  • Dan

    its a shame someone smart enough to get into Stanford cannot see past the transparent lies that have affected this whole issue and victimizes Israel. It was not a peace flotilla, it was a hate flotilla and the media is complicit and part of the lies. Reuters, for example, doctored photographs to eliminate the knife in the hand of the terrorist aboard the boat and even cut out the image of the wounded Israeli soldier who was ambushed aboard ship. The whole point of the ship was to put Israel in a bind and blame it no matter what the outcome.

  • Dan

    its truly shameful someone smart enough to get into Stanford cannot see past the transparent lies that have affected this whole issue and victimizes Israel. It was not a peace flotilla, it was a hate flotilla and the media is complicit and part of the lies. Reuters, for example, doctored photographs to eliminate the knife in the hand of the terrorist aboard the boat and even cut out the image of the wounded Israeli soldier who was ambushed aboard ship. I would put Stanford professors in the category of the self-deluded. The whole point of the ship was to put Israel in a bind and blame it no matter what the outcome.

  • Daniel Jacobs

    Peace activists

    “Hello Uncle Erwin,

    This is Amir writing you after reading what you sent to my father, Eitan. As
    you know, it was my unit and my friends who were on the ship. My commander
    was injured badly as a result of the “pacifists” violence. I want to tell
    you how he was injured so you could tell the story. it shows just how
    horrible and inhuman were the activists. My commander was the first soldier
    that rappelled down from the helicopter to the ship. When he touched ground,
    he got hit in the head with a pole and stabbed in the stomach with a knife.
    When he drew out his secondary weapon-a handgun (his primary weapon was a
    regular paintball gun: “Tippman 98 custom”) he was shot in the leg. He
    managed to fire a single shot before he was tossed from the balcony by 4
    Arab activists, to the lower deck (a 12 feet fall). He was then dragged by
    other activists to a room in the lower deck were he was stripped down by 2
    activists. They took off his vest, helmet and shirt, leaving him with only
    his pants and shoes on. When they finished they took a knife and expanded
    the wound he already had in his stomach. They cut his ab muscles
    horizontally and by hand spilled his guts out. When they finished they
    raised him up and walked him on the deck outside. He was conscious the whole
    time. If you are asking yourself why they did all that, here comes the
    reason. They wanted to show the soldiers their commander’s body so they will
    be demoralized and scared. Luckily, when they walked him on the deck a
    soldier saw him and managed to shoot the activist that was walking him down
    the outside corridor. He shot him with a special non-lethal bullet that
    didn’t kill him. My commander managed to jump from the deck to the water and
    swim to an army rescue boat (his guts still out of his body, and now in
    salty sea water). That was how he was saved. The activists that did this to
    him are alive, now in Turkey, and treated as heroes.

    I’m sorry if I described this with too many details, but I thought it was
    necessary for the credibility. Please tell this story to anyone who will
    listen. I think that these days you are one of Israel’s best spokesman.

    Thanks uncle Erwin, Shabbat shalom!

    Amir

  • Is this a joke?

    What kind of nut cases conduct an airmobile assault with paintball guns as primary weapons?

  • zz

    @Dan The other side has done the same. They were using images they claimed that were from the flotilla showing bulletproof vests, etc, but if you look at the exif data (information stored in the photograph) the photo was from 2007.

  • Dan

    zz Source? Proof? What is the “other side” of the press? Israel?

  • Dan

    Is this a joke?

    Israel had bad intelligence from their intelligence colleagues in Turkey that there would be no resistance aboard the ship, as indeed there was none aboard any of the other ships. They were set up, by prime minister Erdogan. That said, Ehud Barak has some explaining to do.

  • hey

    Agree with Dan. Are the student protestors just so naive and immature and ignorant that they don’t get all the facts before they are out there acting like a bunch of idiots! Now I wonder if they are as smart as they seem. How did they get into Stanford?

  • zz

    I’m not sure why my comments are being added

  • Arafat

    We should let Hamas take over Palo Alto. Or, if not Hamas, then let’s let a bunch of left-wing professors take it over instead. Ultimately I’m not sure the difference is all that great.

  • a, barbara theisen

    ….and Stanford is supposed to educate the brightest? Wow. Learn your history.

  • Araphat

    Poor, poor Hamas. Poor, poor Taliban. Poor, poor Hizbollah. Poor, poor Safdar Nagori. Poor, poor Jabjatful Islamiya. Poor, poor Eritrean Islamic Jihad. Poor, poor Tafkir al-Hijab. Poor, poor Harakat al-Shabaab. Poor, poor Fatah al-Islam. Poor, poor Lashkar-e-Omar. Poor, poor, Ansar al-Islam. Poor, poor Ingush Jamat. Poor, poor Al-Qaeda. Poor, poor Al-Gama’a al Islamiya. Poor, poor Mujahdeen KOMPAK. Poor, poor Hizb-an-Isram.

    All these poor, poor Islamist groups deserve our pity, aid and universal support for their goals and ambitions and values are so close to our hearts.

    If only we loved them without constraint — like Hamas for instance — I’m sure they would love us in return. Just ask some of the leftist professors — like Linda Hess — and they will tell us it is so.

Login to your account

Can't remember your Password ?

Register for this site!